Monday, 25 June 2012

East of East of Suez (taken from Think Defence)

Think Defence has kindly offered me a spot to post occasionally on matters of interest. While many readers of this site are long time TD regulars, I strongly recommend anyone who hasn't been there to take a look.
The text below is the first part of a three part series on the UK engagement in the East of Suez region. The original article can be found at
http://www.thinkdefence.co.uk/2012/06/east-of-east-of-suez-the-uk-military-presence-in-the-asia-pacific-region/
East of East of Suez – the UK commitment to the Asia / Pacific Rim.
The Far East is an area which has long held a fascination for many in the UK – both as a tourist destination, a source of economic prosperity, an emerging powerhouse of influence and dynamism, and a location where over many years the MOD has been engaged in one form or another. The region conjures up images of UK forces fighting in the jungles and seas of the Pacific, of the fall of Singapore, of great national humiliation, and immense pride, in wars such as Korea in the 1950s. Even today the UK contribution in Malaysia and the ‘Confrontation’ Campaign are seen as good examples of how to successfully handle low level insurgencies or military clashes.
The phrase ‘East of Suez’ seems to sum up a generational policy shift in the 1960s, when the UK began the process of recalling the legions, and withdrawing the tens of thousands of troops from the Asia Pacific region, and the drawing down of the great naval fortress of Singapore. In the public eye, the UK ceased to be a military power in the region in the 1970s, and to many our final withdrawal was completed in 1997 with the handover of Hong Kong. Yet, against all odds, and despite the expectations of many, the UK retains a small military presence in the region, and continues to enjoy strong relations with many of the nations present in this fascinating and immensely complex part of the world.
The purpose of this short series of articles is to review the UKs military commitments to the region, to gain an understanding of where UK defence interests lie, and review what it is that the UK is being expected to deliver, and why it benefits the taxpayer to retain an influence in this region. It will be structured over three parts, and should be seen in the context of the wider TD series of Strategy Posts. It does not represent any official viewpoint, and should not be read or construed as being anything other than a personal interpretation of the current UK level of military commitment to the Asia Pacific region.
UK Commitments
For the purposes of this article, the Asia pacific region is deemed to be those nations east of the Indian Ocean, from Singapore through to the pacific coastlines of the Americas. It does not look at the roles played by UK forces in the Indian Ocean itself. Since 1997, the two main physical locations for UK forces in the region have been Brunei and Singapore.
Brunei: The role of the garrison in Brunei has been, at the request of his Majesty the Sultan of Brunei, to provide security for the country as a whole. The UK has had a military presence in Brunei since 1962, when troops landed to provide additional security. Today the garrison comprises some 900 personnel, predominantly drawn from the Ghurkhas’, for whom one battalion of light infantry is usually based in the Kingdom. Additionally, a small flight of helicopters and the UKs primary jungle warfare school (the other being in Belize, which has been downsized in the last year), as well as assorted other staff.
The Sultan meets the costs of the provision of the battalion, and also much of the infrastructure costs associated with their presence. The garrison arrangement is renewed on a five yearly basis between Brunei and the UK. At present the UK presence is scheduled to continue until at least 2015. An excellent summary of the UK defence commitment can be found at the FCO website (http://ukinbrunei.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/working-with-brunei/defence/)
Singapore: The UK presence in Singapore is not known to many in the MOD, let alone outside it. Until 1971 Singapore was home to a not inconsiderable number of UK warships and support vessels, using the dockyard facilities and support networks to provide the Far East Fleet. This organisation continued in a much reduced tri-national (Australia, New Zealand, UK) format until 1976, when the UK then withdrew its final contingents as economic problems forced a final withdrawal from the region.
Despite this, the UK retains to this day the ownership of a large fuel depot, and berthing wharves in Sembewang dockyard. Having been to the site a few years ago, the author can personally attest to its size, which provides berthing access for up to three escorts at a time, plus access to fuel and spare parts. Reportedly the fuel depot is the second largest in the Asia-Pacific region, and provides useful access for UK and allied warships to fuel. The FCO website has a good description of current UK military assets in Singapore – http://ukinsingapore.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/working-with-singapore/defence
These two facilities constitute the only permanent UK military presence in the region in terms of formed units or military installations. There is a wider set of individual exchange posts, particularly in Australia and New Zealand, where a plethora of UK personnel work as integrated members of these nations militaries.
Defence Attaches: One of the most significant UK military contributions in the region in terms of influence is the Defence Attaché network. Although many people are often sceptical of the value of defence attaches (a recent Daily Mail article referred to them as the so-called ‘Ferrero Roche’ network’), there is a strong argument to be made for the retention of these posts.
Attaches provide the UK with the opportunity to put military personnel into the region, to meet with and understand the military issues facing a country, and to get a better feel for strategic developments in a region. Many countries genuinely appreciate a UK Defence Attaché presence – it is seen as a sign that the UK takes their nation seriously from a military perspective, and this presence can often be invaluable in opening doors in an emergency.
In a region like the Far East, the Defence Attaché network represents one of the best means of the MOD to engage with local military forces and continue a relationship, particularly in nations which may rarely see a UK visit. As of November 2010, there were DA’s located in Australia, New Zealand, Brunei, China, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, and Singapore. (Source http://www.theyworkforyou.com/wrans/?id=2010-11-08a.10.0). Additionally, since 1998, posts have closed in the Philippines and Thailand.
Some of these posts are of particular interest, and worthy of note. The two posts in Korea and Japan owe much to the Korean War for their continued existence. As one of the main participants in the war, the UK continues to have a place on the UN Military Armistice Commission, and the position of a 1* helps ensure the UK is engaged in this particular diplomatic issue. Additionally, the presence of military personnel in Japan, where the DA holds the position of UK Liaison Officer to the United Nations Command (Rear) helps ensure that the UK can invoke access to Japanese ports and airfields at short notice under UN resolutions dating back to the war – and as seen during the North Korean nuclear tests some years ago, where the UK sent a radiation sampling VC10 to the region, this is a useful access right to be able to invoke (and also a means of demonstrating continued interest and influence in the region). For further information on the role both sections play, see these links – http://ukinjapan.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/our-embassy/how-we-can-help/defence-section and http://ukinrok.fco.gov.uk/en/about-us/working-with-korea/defence-relations/
For the relatively small outlay of two defence sections, the UK is able to remain not only engaged in, and kept abreast of developments in the Korean peninsula, but also is able to safeguard access into the region. This helps the UK play a small, but influential role, and when coupled with the wider diplomatic presence in both Seoul and Pyongyang, means that the UK can help punch above its weight when it comes to influencing both these nations, and others involved in the delicate diplomatic situation in the region. While this may only be a small example, it does show that often a deft touch with the presence of a military attaché can have significantly wider ramifications for the UK as a whole.
Wider Exercises / Deployments: Although the UK has not had a major permanent military presence in the region for some time, until late in the last decade, regular task group deployments to the region ensured that there was a routine RN presence at least once per year, often in substantial numbers. The Ocean Wave 97 and Taurus 09 deployments are both good examples of the UK deploying substantial forces into the region, using enablers such as amphibious assault capabilities, and also wider surface ship capabilities, to visit a range of nations, conduct exercises under the auspices of regional alliances (such as the Five Power Defence Arrangement), and generally show the UK flag in an area which rarely sees a substantial UK military presence.
The combination of a smaller RN and a busyoperational tasking schedule means that deployments such as these have been less frequent for some time. Although there has been a limited RN surface presence – such as HMS RICHMOND in 2011, the reality is that for the time being, there is likely to be only a limited engagement in the area. The RN is very busy at present, and with a smaller escort fleet and reduced amphibious capability, all of which are in demand for real world operations, it is likely that future deployments to the region will see physically fewer, but materially vastly more capable, vessels operating there. Sadly the days of 10 – 15 vessel deployments such as OCEAN WAVE 97 are likely to have gone forever.
The RAF is also unlikely to see significant non-operational deployments into the region for the time being. The RAF operational fleet remains committed for operations in Afghanistan and elsewhere, and for as long as support to operations in Afghanistan remains the Defence Main Effort, then this is the priority for resources. That said, it is likely that exercises or small deployments, for instance to showcase Typhoon, will continue. As ever, it is important to remember that numbers of aircraft does not directly equate to capability, as both Typhoon and Tornado are immensely capable aircraft.
The Army is the service least likely to deploy in any substantial numbers to the region, although this is in keeping with the wider reality that since the 1960s and the end of Confrontation, the Far East region was far more an RN / RAF operational environment than an Army one. At the same time, the Army has the largest laydown of personnel of any UK service in the region, through the Brunei garrison.
Therefore, at any one time the UK military presence in the Asia Pacific region is just under 1000 permanently based military personnel, including Singapore, Brunei and the Defence Attache network. There are reasonably regular visits by RAF aircraft, and RN vessels, and although vastly smaller than the 1960s, there still remains a relatively substantial UK military presence to the East of East of Suez.
Having considered what the current UK military capabilities and commitments are in the region, the next instalment of this article will consider what possible challenges and threats exist in the region. This will also focus on the role of the FPDA, and wider UK engagement.

39 comments:

  1. Congratulations! I enjoyed reading this article. To me it seemed an accurate description of the decline of the British (military?) influence around the world.
    ""Therefore, at any one time the UK military presence in the Asia Pacific region is just under 1000 permanently based military personnel, including Singapore, Brunei and the Defence Attache network"" and more than 900 of these are in Brunei.
    Which leaves the other 100 spread very thinly around the region.
    Show the flag - influence the decision - help when needed - we can't do any of this.
    Tsunami 2004 was a classic example of our inability to help.
    Sometimes I wish that people would understand what we are now, compared to what we used to be.
    We are a third rate country, drowning in debt and corruption, and living on our past glories.
    Our one redeeming feature is the Armed Forces and yet we have let them down.
    I am one of the "Old and not so Bold" I get all my information from books,newspapers,magazines, and the internet. Sometimes I visit what used to be called "far flung outposts of the Empire" and study the changes that have taken place since we left. Nobody remembers us and I doubt that we have any influence anywhere except in the minds of Whitehall Warriors and civil servants.
    As I said - Thank you for an interesting article and I look forward( as usual ) to your next missive.

    ReplyDelete
  2. An interesting post and I look forward to reading the next two on this subject. Whether the underlying aspirations for the UK are realistic, I'm not sure. In a post on my own blog I posed the question "Are we trapped in the invidious position, primarily in population terms, of being too large to occupy a niche, but too small to be a player?" but I didn't attempt to answer it! http://westernindependent.blogspot.com/2012/06/with-no-particular-place-to-go.html
    By the way, who said "I imagine historians will best remember my six years at the Ministry of Defence for the liquidation of Britain's military role outside Europe, an anachronism which was essentially a legacy from our nineteenth-century empire."?
    Answer here http://westernindependent.blogspot.com/2011/07/healey-on-defence-and-carriers.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi thanks for sharing the information.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The talk about Singapore is spot on. But as of for many years since 1997, RN deployments to Singapore have been extremely rare. Those facilities are underused.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Welcome to 24 Online Mumbai Escorts Agency the hotel of the attractive god, wherever attractiveness and cleverness dwells in! Be enthralled and fascinated by acumen to please their customers with best featherbed and different Mumbai Escorts services and Escort Agency Expertise being one of the globes as our women is aware of the way to our discriminating customers with rattling care and enjoy. Make a choice from our big range of difficult women was well electing to 100% satisfy the requirements of our high-end company.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Mumbai Female Escorts
    24 Online Mumbai Escorts
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ruhi Gupta Escort in Mumbai all our Independent Mumbai Escorts are best at satisfying all of your wishes and can clear each one of the load and restlessness. We give our clients a necessary encounter and can help them in throwing all hindrances. Return to Indian country and just like the best for your life time.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Independent Mumbai Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Ruhi Gupta
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  7. Welcome to Open 24 Escorts Mumbai Escorts agency wherever all of your thoughts return true with any of our superb low-cost city escorts. We provide a large assortment of women here at our Mumbai Escort agency that starts from and that we recognize that you simply can have the time of your life for just that worth that you won’t be able to get at the other High Escorts agency to the common that we offer.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Agency
    Open 24 Escorts
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  8. Kalpna Rai Escorts in Mumbai place stock in doing no matter we have to try to provide 100% secure client satisfaction through our organizations. We tend to equally merely contract vernal girls that have a similar mentality that is that the reason; our Agency Escorts continue being the cleanest provider of hot Mumbai Escorts Service all told of city.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Independent Mumbai Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Kalpna Rai
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  9. The first glimpse that you have of these girls is through the wide gallery of the pictures that are displayed on the website. The agencies feature only the recent photographs of these asian wonder girls.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Welcome to 24 Hours Mumbai Escorts as one of the leading Mumbai Escort city Agency in city Mumbai Escort, we have a tendency to provide customer with a high class service that actually may be a cut higher than your average escort agency. We have a leaning to focus on High category Escorts city, and once it involves choosing your escort, you all take in that there's for all time a group of actually dramatic ladies out there.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Agency
    24 Hours Mumbai Escorts
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  11. Welcome to Chennai Escorts the all new Escort index devoted to transferrable you the best that the net must provide to Chennai Escort Services in city center. We have listed the best native city center Escorts Chennai. These women square measure clever and well refined Independent Chennai Escorts.
    Chennai Escorts
    Escorts in Chennai
    Chennai Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Chennai
    Independent Chennai Escorts

    Mansi Gupta
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  12. Beautiful Ishika is a Independent escorts in Bangalore woman. Her lovely face radiate with attractiveness and youngsters.



    Bangalore Escorts
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Escorts in Bangalore
    Escorts Service in Bangalore
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Bangalore Female Escorts

    Thanks
    Ishika Bangalore Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  13. Welcome to escorts in bangalore service provider erotic and beauty of bangalore escorts, escorts service in bangalore.


    Bangalore Escorts
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Escorts in Bangalore
    Escorts Service in Bangalore
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Bangalore Female Escorts

    Thanks
    Escort-Bangalore Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  14. All profiles listed on this website Pune Escorts sponsored ads from out high Class Pune escort sites! All you have got to try to be visit these sites and search the net file, and you are accessible with a listing of native Independent escorts in Pune urban center space.
    Pune Escorts
    Escorts in Pune
    Pune Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Pune
    Independent Pune Escorts

    Anu Radha Rathor
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thus once you notice the one you wish, don’t hesitate to decision her and begin a time and place to attach. If for a few bases she is not accessible at present, then just select another Chennai escort that you just like, and speak to her. It’s that simple.
    Chennai Escorts
    Escorts in Chennai
    Chennai Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Chennai
    Independent Chennai Escorts

    Hansika Bhat
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  16. Green Chennai Escorts to Independent Chennai Escorts Girl from city Escort and can stir you into their tasty Indian of Chennai entice, a haven of good-looking charm where you may be fancy, guard and into a state of lovely joy.
    Chennai Escorts
    Chennai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Chennai
    Escorts Service in Chennai
    Chennai Escorts Service

    Green Chennai Escorts
    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  17. The east area basically related to fun and nightlife and i have been there for fun. It was amazing experience.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Welcome to Delicacy Hyderabad Escorts, Hyderabad Female Escorts friendship in varied party, events, or geological dating functions.
    Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Agency
    Hyderabad Escorts Girls
    Hyderabad Female Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  19. Simran Sharma Oh Nice Hello Guy's Our hot Bangalore Escorts accepts completion by conveyance of title our customers with society that's each fulfilling and 100% satisfying.
    Bangalore Escorts
    Independent Bangalore Escorts
    Escorts in Bangalore
    Escorts Service in Bangalore
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Bangalore Escorts Services

    ReplyDelete
  20. nikhita-bansal.com is Bangalore leading supplier in up market lady Escort Company. With our assortment of gorgeous models out there 24/7 for call service in Bangalore, BANGALORE, we tend to guarantee that we have got the simplest lady escorts in BANGALORE.
    Bangalore Escorts
    Independent Bangalore Escorts
    Escorts in Bangalore
    Escorts Service in Bangalore
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Bangalore



    nikhita-bansal.com is Bangalore leading supplier in up market lady Escort Company. With our assortment of gorgeous models out there 24/7 for call service in Bangalore, BANGALORE, we tend to guarantee that we have got the simplest lady escorts in BANGALORE. At nikhita-bansal.com we attempt to deliver a secure and discreet expertise to our shoppers. Those seeking to seek out high Class escorts in Bangalore and encompassing areas ought to grasp that nikhita-bansal.com prides itself in client 100% satisfaction and that we encourage a Bangalore feedback that will higher your expertise.

    ReplyDelete
  21. At our website of Mylovehyderabadfemaleescorts.com we would like to introduce you towards a wide overview of high class escorts in Hyderabad.
    Hyderabad Escorts
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Hyderabad
    Female Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Girls
    My Love Hyderabad Female Escorts

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  22. Our agency consists of the most effectual in Hyderabad Escorts with young, wise attempt and in type lingerie models, educate ladies, actors and regular ladies neighboring.


    Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Escorts Service in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Service

    Thanks
    Elfish Hyderabad Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  23. We present a good assortment Delicacy Hyderabad Escorts of escorts whose cost is bounded by the leading ready for action in Hyderabad Escorts. For exact and complete particulars of cost satisfy converse over with individual sites.
    Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Escorts Service in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Service

    Thanks
    Delicacy Hyderabad Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hi, I’m kalpana rai represent and I offer Out-Call VIP Mumbai Escorts Service be so more than a few Mumbai Escorts other than we be the most outstanding for the cause that we know that clientele are central, therefore, we teach our girls, that they will have to please the clients at any cost.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Independent Mumbai Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Service

    Thanks
    Kalpna Rai

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi, I’m Poonam malik and I am 24 years old Independent Escorts in Mumbai. She is a lovable fair-haired by means of a slim figure. Whatsoever the scene, you will absolutely have absolute pleasure with me. She is an unbiased, an indisputable gorgeousness, and a devoid of accuse spirit who enjoy treat her customers to an out of this world understanding.
    Mumbai Escorts
    Independent Mumbai Escorts
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Service

    Thanks
    Poonam Malik

    ReplyDelete
  26. Welcome to Hyderabad Escorts Service. For a worry-free holiday of a lifetime in the land of sexy smiles, Hyderabad Escorts will give you everything you desire.
    Hyderabad Escorts
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts Service in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Girls
    Welcome Spicy Hyderabad Escorts Service

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  27. Our Hyderabad escort agency inwards on the Hyderabad escort scene this year and that we have taken the business by storm.
    Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Agency
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Call Girls
    Hyderabad Escorts Service

    Thanks
    Elfish Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  28. Welcome to Hyderabad Escorts Agency Hyderabad Escorts, because the name suggests, we have a tendency to are here to assist you discover your good Girlfriend expertise in Hyderabad.


    Hyderabad Escorts
    Hyderabad Escorts Service
    Escorts in Hyderabad
    Escorts Service in Hyderabad
    Hyderabad Escorts Agency
    Hyderabad Female Escorts

    Thanks
    Golden Hyderabad Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  29. There are many services that in Mumbai Escorts will offer at affordable prices and in a convenient as well as reliable manner which you can consider whenever need arises.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Agency
    Mumbai Female Escorts

    Thanks
    24 Hours Mumbai Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  30. A world high class Escort Service in Bangalore headed by a group of specific customer supervision groups this Bangalore Escorts Agency by stands separated from the rest.
    Bangalore Escorts
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Escorts in Bangalore
    Escorts Service in Bangalore
    Bangalore Escorts Service
    Bangalore Female Escorts

    Thanks
    Escort-Bangalore Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hello Guy's our hot Mumbai Escorts accepts conclusion by transportation of title our clientele with civilization that's each satisfying and 100% pleasing.


    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Escorts in Mumbai
    Escorts Service in Mumbai
    Mumbai Escorts Agency
    Mumbai Female Escorts

    Thanks
    24 Online Mumbai Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  32. Great post! Thanks you so much for the share. Keep up the Excellent work, we look forward to reading more from you in the future!

    Singapore Escort Services | Singapore Female Escorts

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hello Guys my self yamini das offer bangalore escorts services. If you are in Bangalore and want to enjoy with very gorgeous and seductive Bangalore escorts. yamini das is one of the most sensual call girl provides ultimate services.

    ReplyDelete